Today I’m wrestling with one of those pesky blogger dilemmas: I want to tell a story. But it’s not my story to tell.
I don’t even know all the details. I wasn’t there from the beginning. I can’t even say how it ends. Not really. But no one else is going to tell it. And it deserves to be told.
It’s a love story. A first love story, as in, the first embodiment of love I was ever privy to, the prototype, as it were, for love in my family. It’s the love between my grandmother and grandfather.
Here’s what I know:
They met right before the war. Or maybe it was right after, when he’d returned from the Merchant Marines. (See? I’m going to get things wrong.) They were both attending Occidental in Southern California, and revolved within the same circle of friends. He received a box of See’s Candies from his parents on a June afternoon. He offered her one. She accepted. She inquired as to the occasion, and he told her it was his birthday. What she didn’t tell him (not until later): it was her birthday, as well. That same day. Of the same year.
They’d spend the next 60 and change celebrating it together.
They were poor, but only at first. And only in a ‘have to prove yourself’ kind of way. (His parents were well off, hers did alright.) They had a little house in Pasadena, one car, and one job (his) working his way up the corporate ladder at a Los Angeles insurance firm. They had three babies in six years. She had coiffed hair and manicured nails and a beautiful figure (and was always on a fad diet). She was a homemaker and a member of the ‘mending club’ and never failed to have two cocktails at the ready at 6 pm, dinner served at 7. (She used to tell my mother and her brothers to ride their tricycles through the family room before he came home from work; the carpet ruts from the metal wheels made it look as though she’d recently vacuumed.)
She was immensely proud of him. He was immensely proud of her. I could see this clearly, even from my childhood vantage point, decades later.
They threw dinner parties. They shared a deep love of world travel. He took her on business trips to London and Paris and New York. (The first time my grandmother flew on an airplane was with him.) He was a devoted family man, if in the old-fashioned sense of the term. She ran the baths, checked the homework, dried the tears. He wrote the checks, attended the graduations, gave the toasts at the weddings. They survived unstable economies, family turmoil, and the ’60s together. He reached the top of that corporate ladder. They bought a bigger house, then a home on the beach. She went back to college for a teaching degree and taught the children of migrant workers in impoverished schools. (She still had cocktails on the table by 7 pm.)
They played a mean game of tennis (always pairs) and a meaner game of bridge, the ice in their cocktail glasses tinkling like chimes when they set them on their coasters to play a hand.
They weren’t perfect, although they seemed nearly so to me. They both smoked like chimneys. (Until they didn’t. He quit cold turkey, so she did, too.) They had grandchildren. I was one of them, of course. My grandfather was still enjoying the view from the top corporate rung, so every morning, she’d get up when he did (4:30 am) to make him coffee and fresh-squeezed juice and eggs over-easy on toast before his commute. When I was there, I’d wait for him in the breakfast nook so I could hand him the L.A. Times, still rubber-banded and folded crisp. He’d shake it out and give me the funnies (then ask for them back once he’d read the finance page).
He read novels to us kids: A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court, David Copperfield, Great Expectations. He was the man among men type: smarter than us, wittier than us, better-read than us, first to state the answer to Double Jeopardy. She was the one we could cozy up to and spill our secrets. She was the one who spoiled us.
They were products of their time, certainly, and also products of each other: growing up, I watched frame after frame of the two of them in Kodak slides of every international trip they took, arms locked around one another, back to some landmark, faces tipped to the camera. (He was tall, she is short.)
And here’s how I know this love was the real thing (and this is the part of the story I don’t want to tell):
When he died, I think she expected to as well. In fact, I think she’s continually surprised to find she hasn’t. Three years ago, when I entered the hospital room that became his deathbed, the first thing I saw was him, no longer larger than life. And the second thing I saw was her, also altered so drastically she mirrored his wasted state: shoulders hunched, sitting in the corner where his head rested on a pillow, a look in her eyes that didn’t reflect, only absorbed. When I greeted her, she blinked once, like a question.
She was, in a word (and such a cliched word), lost.
Today, she’s 86. We love her. We know she loves us. But she’s only half here. The other half is spent in bed, covers over her head, refusing to stir. Where she is in her mind, I don’t know. I think nowhere. I think she’s trying to be no one.
We rouse her. We remind her to eat. We remind her to dress. We tell her about our day, about our kids, about our friends and their friends and whatever interesting anecdotes we can provide. We talk books and movies and culture. She reads our recommendations. She watches and listens.
But not really.
And there’s nothing we can do. Because we’re not who she wants. And the passage of time does not make things easier. It does not soften the blow. It does not blur the edges. (I thought this was Time’s main guarantee?) And so we’re forced to watch her manage a pain every day that we cannot touch. That we cannot bear in her place. It’s really very awful. Instead, we’re left to manage her pills and her blood pressure and her sodium intake.
We love her, and she loves us. She does. She does. She loves my mother and her brothers and all the grandkids and great-grandkids and if she really tries, if she exerts all her 86-year-old strength, she can find a pocket of joy here and there. In the instant our wine glasses clink together at a restaurant. When a baby with a gummy smile sits on her lap. While a little boy tries to beat in her chess. When her daughter gives her a hug.
But then that person has gone home or run outside to play or turned to answer the phone or stir the sauce on the stove and her grip on happiness slips and and she falls (back into bed, back under the covers). And she’s marking time again, because it’s not enough. We’re not enough. She’s been severed, and it would seem she cannot be made whole.
And I wasn’t sure I wanted to write about this part because who am I to tell it like it is? I don’t know how it is. I wasn’t there…not for the past 60 years, and certainly not from the perspective that deserves telling. I’ve been married for 14 years, not over half a century. 14 years…it’s a blip. A mere speck on the time line of her life. What do I know, really, of love? True love? First and foremost love?
Enough to venture the guess that not many of us experience it in this lifetime. Not like she did. Not like I suspect she still does.
(I don’t know whether she’d say she’s lucky.)
Written for the Writer’s Workshop prompt, ‘bold’ and The Red Dress Club prompt, ‘first love’.












{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }
AMY! This was beautiful and heartwrenching and just plain awesome. I love the little details (the tricycle tracks on the carpet) and the bigger message (what if Time doesn’t keep its promise to heal?) You done good, kid. Love it.
ps: A great-aunt of mine seemed to be “vacant” and deteriorating rapidly after the death of her husband. She was so changed 2 years after his death that the doctors diagnosed Alzheimers. Then a young internist suggested a blood work-up and they found that she was grossly lacking in B6 and B12 vitamins (she hadn’t had much enthusiasm for eating since her loss). After treatment for that, she was almost her old self, just sadder. I know that’s probably not your grandmother’s situation, but I thought it was worth a mention. xoxo
This is such a beautiful story. You tell it so well. I was recently reading letters from my husband’s grandfather to his grandmother during the war.
Sometimes (and I’m not completely sure about this) I think that our grandparents knew about and enjoyed a different kind of love than our generation knows.
I’m sure it’s hard to see her day in, day out wanting someone, something she can’t have. After reading this, I wonder, is it really better to have loved and lost than to never loved at all? I don’t know. Thanks so much for sharing this!
I couldn’t choose a word from the writer’s workshop this week:
http://doithalfway.wordpress.com/2010/12/09/simple-angsty-excruciating-enchanted-bold/
Christan/MamaBearPing recently posted..A few Words more orless Wednesday
This was beautiful. The writing. The sentiment. The enduring love. Thanks for sharing.
Rudri recently posted..What 131 Means To Me
this was absolutely beautiful and yet filled with sadness. what a great love story.
So beautiful, and so sad. I can feel the lost-ness… the sadness… the emptiness inside that she must be dealing with right now. To know that her whole world is gone, and she is just waiting to be able to join him.
This is a fitting tribute to a profound love, and I am sure she would love to know that their love lives on, in the stories, in the memories, in your writing.
~ifer recently posted..Bittersweet Memories…
Oh, Amy, what a wonderful piece. Your writing is beautiful and the story you recount is powerful and bittersweet. I hope that you will save a copy of this for each of your boys so that they can know their great-grandparents that much better when they are old enough to wonder more about where (and whom) they’re from.
Kristen @ Motherese recently posted..Girls Just Want to Have Fun
Such a touching story. I hate thinking about getting old, wondering if I will off myself when Dumb Dad kicks the bucket. It sound macabre, but I honestly do think of it that way. Even after these few short years I can’t really imagine a life without him. Well, I can imagine, but you know, he seems to fit nicely beside me. Please promise not to bring this up if we wind up on Divorce Court in 6 years.
Dumb Mom recently posted..Dumb Mom’s Simple Life
this was heartachingly, breathtakingly exactly right. Not perfect, just exactly right. Which is what life – and a good marriage – is: not perfect, just exactly right. I sometimes wonder why our modern lives seem so much more difficult, more shades of grey, more complicated. Another question for another day.
This was beautiful.
Kirsten recently posted..And so goes November
Beautiful, Amy, just beautiful. What a love story. And so perfectly told.
I am really glad you wrote this. You nailed it, you really did, as best you can from your view. I too have been married 14 years… when I look at older widows and widowers reeling from grief, I wonder how I’d handle it after 50 years of togetherness. Great job, love it.
Sue recently posted..Fast Times
I agree, this was beautiful in both story and the telling. Visiting from RDC
Kim recently posted..Sexy vampires make me want to vomit
This is one of the most beautiful posts that I have ever read. Your grandparents generation has always had my admiration and respect for the lives they led despite the circumstances they lived through. Well done.
Valerie recently posted..First Love
That is the most beautiful story. I think I could easily put my own grandparents in that tale, so much is similar except it was my grandmother who died first, much too soon, and my grandfather who became a shell of his former self. However, he was lucky to find a new companion to share his life with and now he’s happier. It’s not the same but…
Visiting from Red Writing Hood.
Carrie recently posted..Red Writing Hood- Love Defined
Amy, this is so beautiful. I completely understand as well. My grandmother was the same way after my grandfather passed away. The unfortunate thing was that she lived (existed?) another 28 years until they were together again.
Cathy recently posted..experiences that make you feel older
This is wonderfully told, my grandfather went through a similar period when his wife died, luckily he pulled out of it. I love that you dare to ask if she was lucky or not. How much I wish there was never a price to loving.
Jennifer recently posted..Strawberry Fields
I am blown away by this post. Thank you for sharing this story. You really are an amazing writer.
To tell you that you touched a place so deep inside of me that I feel torn open would be an understatement.
My grandparents had a love like this. My grandfather died just over ten years ago now and my grandmother is still lost without him. It’s as though he was her mirror and without him, she doesn’t exist. She loves the rest of us, but it’s almost as though she feels the joy she could feel isn’t true joy if he isn’t there to witness it with her.
What brings her the most joy is when we ask her to tell us stories about my grandfather, what he was like when he was young, what kind of father and husband he was. That is when she is most like the woman she was when he was still here.
You told their story so beautifully, Amy. So lovely.
These are my favorite stories..the ones where the love is so strong and deep. And you told it well. For this moment, she was my grandmother also, loving me from afar. Beautifully written.
The Drama Mama recently posted..Red Writing Hood- That Thing Called Love
This is such a beautiful story. Thanks for sharing, even if you didn’t want to. It just shows how powerful love really is.
It sounds just like my grandparents. My granddad died 4 years ago, and she hasn’t been the same since. Sometimes I forget how hard it must be for her to have lost her best friend, I would be crazy if it happened to me. And like you said, I haven’t even known my husband a fraction of their life they spent together. Thanks you for reminding me.
Alicia recently posted..Dunk Tank
What a beautiful and moving post.
The first time I thought about love, really thought about love, it was brought on by a conversation with my great-grandmother. As we both grew older, I was sent over more and more throughout summers and weekends to help her while she still lived in her own house. I would help her clean, take out the trash, bring over groceries, and cook– with her instructions, of course– leaving enough cooked meals in her refrigerator to last her throughout the week. She would tell me wonderful stories of her life in return.
One day, when I walked in, I found her sobbing on the couch by the phone. She was not hurt, in the physical sense. It was not the anniversary of some dreadful event. She had received a wrong number call, and the man’s voice on the phone reminded her so much of her husband– gone for over a dozen years by this point– that she immediately broke into tears. “I never stop missing him,” she told me. “I never seem to stop waiting to see him again.”
Sarah recently posted..Holiday Joys
that is a beautiful and heart wrenching story. What a legacy of love. I cannot imagine being married that long, though I hope & pray for that amazing blessing. my heart hurts for your grandmother & her heavy, heavy loss.
Grace @ Arms Wide Open recently posted..simple
Marking time, that’s exactly what it must be like. I dread having to know for myself. I wish your grandmother peace, however she can find it, even it’s buried under the covers in her dreams.
Stacia recently posted..Haiku Friday
I know I am sending this in the middle of the holidays but I would love a guest post from you, even if it is a repost of something you have already published or an excerpt. I do a segment where I share something truthful with my readers, and this post really struck me.
(Florida) Girl with a New Life recently posted..Your Advice- The Driving Force
Heart-wrenching & poignant.. Such a beautiful love story. THIS right here? Is a real fairy tale.
Brought tears to my eyes… amazing…